Editing Waltharius436

Jump to: navigation, search

Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision Your text
Line 308: Line 308:
 
|
 
|
 
|{{Meter|scansion=SDDDDS}}
 
|{{Meter|scansion=SDDDDS}}
| {{Comment|These lines carry powerful rhetorical affect. The reader (or hearer) knows nothing as yet about Gunther’s personality, and may be looking forward to a reunion between the companions Hagan and Walter. The revelation comes as a shock that Gunther, far from promoting good will and solidarity against the Huns, will pose a threat when Walter expects friendship! Moreover, it becomes immediately clear that Hagan will have to choose between his best friend and his lord, two highly sacred relationships in Germanic culture. MCD}}
+
| {{Comment|These lines carry powerful rhetorical affect. The reader (or hearer) knows nothing as yet about Gunther’s personality, and may be looking forward to a reunion between the companions Hagan and Walter. The revelation that Gunther, far from promoting good will and solidarity against the Huns, will pose a threat when Walter expects friendship comes as a shock! Moreover, it becomes immediately clear that Hagan will have to choose between his best friend and his lord, two highly sacred relationships in Germanic culture. MCD}}
 
|-
 
|-
 
|[[Gazam]], [[quam2|quam]] [[Gibicho]] [[regi1|regi]] [[transmisit]] [[eoo]],
 
|[[Gazam]], [[quam2|quam]] [[Gibicho]] [[regi1|regi]] [[transmisit]] [[eoo]],
Line 327: Line 327:
 
|
 
|
 
|{{Meter|scansion=DDSDDS}}
 
|{{Meter|scansion=DDSDDS}}
| {{Comment|Despite being unquestionably greedy and unrighteously avaricious, Gunther does not simply desire money that in no way belongs to him. He is not exactly a thug, though he might behave like one. Gunther feels himself entitled to the Hunnish treasure because he resents the tribute his own father gave to the Huns to establish a treaty. He apparently regards all Hunnish riches as, in some sense, stolen from the Franks and from him.  
+
| {{Comment|Gunther is unquestionably greedy and unrighteously avaricious, in the mind of the Waltharius- poet, but it is important to understand that he does not simply desire money that in no way belongs to him. Gunther is not exactly a thug, though he might behave like one. Gunther feels himself entitled to the Hunnish treasure that Walter bears because he resents the treasure his own father gave to the Huns to establish a treaty. He apparently regards all Hunnish riches as, in some sense, stolen from the Franks and from him.  
"cunctipotens": all-powerful one, presumably God. The singular invocation suggests that Gunther might be Christian, although in general throughout the poem he represents the older, Germanic warrior ethos in all its problematic glory. MCD [Good point: so far as I can remember, the adjective is used solely of the Christian God. The epithet might be useful in dating the poem: check the Thesaurus Linguae Latinae and the Mittellateinisches Worterbuch sub voce. JZ]}}
+
"cunctipotens": all-powerful one, presumably God. The singular invocation suggests that Gunther might be Christian, although in general throughout the poem he represents the older, Germanic warrior ethos in all its problematic glory. MCD}}
 
|-
 
|-
 
|[[haec4|Haec]] [[ait]] [[et]] [[mensam]] [[pede]] [[perculit]] [[exiliensque]]
 
|[[haec4|Haec]] [[ait]] [[et]] [[mensam]] [[pede]] [[perculit]] [[exiliensque]]
Line 341: Line 341:
 
|
 
|
 
|
 
|
|{{Parallel|''Aeneid'' 10.858: ''equum duci iubet.'' ‘He bids his horse be brought.’
+
|{{Parallel|''Aeineid'' 10.858: ''equum duci iubet.'' ‘He bids his horse be brought.’
 
}}
 
}}
 
|
 
|
Line 386: Line 386:
 
|
 
|
 
|{{Meter|scansion=DSDSDS}}
 
|{{Meter|scansion=DSDSDS}}
|{{Comment|Gunther has placed Hagan in an almost unbearable position in which he will be forced to betray one of his vows unless he can dissuade the king. Ward argues that for breaking his vow Hagan in punished with the loss of his eye and his teeth (Roman Epic, ed. Boyle, 1993). It is difficult to see, however, what Hagan could have done differently. The Waltharius-poet may be attempting to show the limitations of the Germanic warrior-ethos, which in his view limits ethical behavior. MCD}}
+
|{{Comment|Gunther has placed Hagan in an almost unbearable position in which he will be forced to betray one of his vows unless he can dissuade the king. Ward argues that Hagan in punished for breaking his vow with the loss of his eye and his teeth (Roman Epic, ed. Boyle, 1993). It is difficult to see, however, what Hagan could have done differently. The Waltharius-poet may be attempting to show the limitations of the Germanic warrior-ethos, which in his eyes limits ethical behavior. MCD}}
 
|
 
|
 
|-
 
|-
Line 404: Line 404:
 
|
 
|
 
|
 
|
|{{Parallel|: ''Aeneid'' 1.101; 8.539; 12.328: ''fortia corpora. . .'' ‘Bodies of the brave. . .’
+
|{{Parallel|: ''Aeineid'' 1.101; 8.539; 12.328: ''fortia corpora. . .'' ‘Bodies of the brave. . .’
 
}}
 
}}
 
|
 
|
Line 413: Line 413:
 
|
 
|
 
|
 
|
|{{Parallel|: ''Aeneid'' 1.101; 8.539; 12.328: ''fortia corpora. . .'' ‘Bodies of the brave. . .’
+
|{{Parallel|: ''Aeineid'' 1.101; 8.539; 12.328: ''fortia corpora. . .'' ‘Bodies of the brave. . .’
 
<br />Prudentius, ''Hamartigenia'' 423: ''. . .squamosum thoraca gerens de pelle colubri. '' ‘. . .Wearing a scaly breast-plate of snakeskin.’
 
<br />Prudentius, ''Hamartigenia'' 423: ''. . .squamosum thoraca gerens de pelle colubri. '' ‘. . .Wearing a scaly breast-plate of snakeskin.’
 
}}
 
}}
 
|
 
|
 
|{{Meter|scansion=DSSSDS}}
 
|{{Meter|scansion=DSSSDS}}
|{{Comment|"Squamosus": literally, "scaly." This image not only captures the appearance of closely-woven Germanic corslets but also brings interesting reptilian associations to Hagan and his men. Dragons, traditional symbols of greed, are often described in terms of their impenetrable scales (as in Beowulf, ll. 2574-2680). By putting on scales, Gunther and his men become less than men, half-beasts transformed by greed. Indeed, in medieval literature dragons are occasionally imagined as demonic versions of men. In the late medieval English romance Bevis of Hampton, two greedy and warring lords are transformed by the Devil into dragons and terrorize Germany and Italy.}}
+
|{{Comment|"Squamosus": literally, scaly. It is a powerful image which captures the appearance of closely-woven Germanic corslets, but it also brings interesting reptilian associations to Hagan and his men. Dragons, traditional symbols of greed, are often described in terms of their impenetrable scales (as in Beowulf, ll. 2574-2680). By putting on scales, Gunther and his men become less than men, half-beasts transformed by greed. Indeed, in medieval literature dragons are occasionally imagined as demonic versions of men. In the late medieval English romance Bevis of Hampton, two greedy and warring lords are transformed by the Devil into dragons and terrorize Germany and Italy.}}
 
|-
 
|-
 
|[[hic2|Hic]] [[tantum1|tantum]] [[gazae]] [[Francis]] [[deducat]] [[ab|ab ]][[oris]]?'
 
|[[hic2|Hic]] [[tantum1|tantum]] [[gazae]] [[Francis]] [[deducat]] [[ab|ab ]][[oris]]?'
Line 453: Line 453:
 
|
 
|
 
|{{Meter|scansion=DSSSDS|elision=cernere et}}
 
|{{Meter|scansion=DSSSDS|elision=cernere et}}
|{{Comment|"imbellum": literally, "unwarlike." Despite the ferryman's description of the bellicose passenger, Gunther and his men imagine that Walther will be easy to overcome. The disjunction emphasizes further Gunther's overweening pride and greed. This is an instance of dramatic irony on the part of the Waltharius-poet (see Green, Irony in the Medieval Romance, 1979). MCD}}
+
|{{Comment|"imbellum": literally, "unwarlike one." Despite the ferryman's undeniably bellicose description, Gunther and his men imagine Walther will be easy to overcome. I suspect this is not meant to sound at all logical, in order to emphasize further Gunther's overweening pride and greed. This is an instance of dramatic irony on the part of the Waltharius-poet (see Green, Irony in the Medieval Romance, 1979). MCD}}
 
|-
 
|-
 
|[[sed1|Sed]] [[tamen1|tamen]] [[omnimodis]] [[Hagano]] [[prohibere]] [[studebat]],
 
|[[sed1|Sed]] [[tamen1|tamen]] [[omnimodis]] [[Hagano]] [[prohibere]] [[studebat]],
Line 469: Line 469:
 
|
 
|
 
|{{Meter|scansion=SSSDDS}}
 
|{{Meter|scansion=SSSDDS}}
|{{Comment|Kratz translates "infelix" as "ill-starred," a somewhat figurative rendering. Literally, the word can denote infertility, as in Virgil's Georgics, 2.237-239 ("intereunt segetes, subit aspera silva, / lappaeque tribolique, interque nitentia culta /infelix lolium et steriles dominantur avena.") It also comes to carry the meaning of unhappiness, even denoting someone who causes unhappiness. This last definition might best describe the troublemaker Gunther, though the word's connotations of infertility also ominously foreshadow Gunther's fate. MCD}}
+
|{{Comment|Kratz translates "infelix" as "ill-starred," a somewhat figurative rendering. Literally, the word denotes infertility, as in Virgil's Georgics, 2.237-239 ("intereunt segetes, subit aspera silva, / lappaeque tribolique, interque nitentia culta /infelix lolium et steriles dominantur avena.") It also comes to carry the meaning of unhappiness, even denoting someone who causes unhappiness. This last definition might best describe the troublemaker Gunther, though the word's connotations of infertility also ominously foreshadow Gunther's fate. MCD}}
 
|-
 
|-
 
|}
 
|}

Please note that all contributions to Waltharius may be edited, altered, or removed by other contributors. If you do not want your writing to be edited mercilessly, then do not submit it here.
You are also promising us that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource (see Waltharius:Copyrights for details). Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!

Cancel Editing help (opens in new window)