Difference between revisions of "Waltharius170"
| (20 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 29: | Line 29: | ||
|nowrap | [[Et]] [[bellatorum]] [[confortat]] [[corda]] [[suorum]], | |nowrap | [[Et]] [[bellatorum]] [[confortat]] [[corda]] [[suorum]], | ||
|175 | |175 | ||
| − | |{{Commentary|''Confortat'' = ''confirmat'' | + | |{{Commentary|''Confortat'' = ''confirmat'' |
| + | }} | ||
| + | |{{Parallel|2 Sam. 11.25 Vulg.: ''conforta bellatores.'' “Encourage thy warriors.”<br />Gen. 18.5 Vulg.: ''confortate cor vestrum.'' “Strengthen ye your heart.” | ||
}} | }} | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Line 38: | Line 40: | ||
|nowrap | [[Promittensque]] [[istos]] [[solita]] [[virtute]] [[tyrannos]] | |nowrap | [[Promittensque]] [[istos]] [[solita]] [[virtute]] [[tyrannos]] | ||
| | | | ||
| − | |{{Commentary|''Tyrannos'' = ''rebelles'' (here, cf. line 1384). ''Tyrannus'' has a wide semantic range (Neidorf 2025, note on line 886).<br />'' | + | |{{Commentary|''Tyrannos'' = ''rebelles'' (here, cf. line 1384). ''Tyrannus'' has a wide semantic range (Neidorf 2025, note on line 886).<br />''Solita virtute'': reference to the description in the ''Psychomachia'' of ''Patientia'' (Suffering), who explicitly does not win battles by fighting (see ''Psychomachia'' 155–159) |
}} | }} | ||
|{{Parallel|Prudentius, ''Psychomachia'' 155–56: ''“vicimus,” inquit, / “exultans Vitium solita virtute.”'' “‘We have overcome,’ he said, ‘a proud Vice with our wonted virtue.’”<br />''Aeneid'' 11.415: ''quamquam o si solitae quicquam virtutis adesset!'' “If only we had any of our wonted valour!” | |{{Parallel|Prudentius, ''Psychomachia'' 155–56: ''“vicimus,” inquit, / “exultans Vitium solita virtute.”'' “‘We have overcome,’ he said, ‘a proud Vice with our wonted virtue.’”<br />''Aeneid'' 11.415: ''quamquam o si solitae quicquam virtutis adesset!'' “If only we had any of our wonted valour!” | ||
| Line 50: | Line 52: | ||
| | | | ||
| | | | ||
| − | |{{Parallel|Josh. | + | |{{Parallel|Josh. 8.3 Vulg.: ''surrexit Iosue et omnis exercitus bellatorum cum eo.'' “And Josue arose, and all the army of the fighting men with him.”<br />''Aeneid'' 2.415: ''exercitus omnis…'' “The whole host…”<br />11.597–99: ''At manus interea muris Troiana propinquat, / Etruscique duces equitumque exercitus omnis / compositi numero in turmas.'' “But meanwhile the Trojan band draws near the walls, with the Etruscan chiefs and all their mounted array, marshalled by number into squadrons.” |
}} | }} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|nowrap | [[Ecce]] [[locum]] [[pugnae]] [[conspexerat]] [[et]] [[numeratam]] | |nowrap | [[Ecce]] [[locum]] [[pugnae]] [[conspexerat]] [[et]] [[numeratam]] | ||
|180 | |180 | ||
| − | |{{Commentary|The description of the battle that follows reworks a scene from the Aeneid (11. | + | |{{Commentary|The description of the battle that follows reworks a scene from the Aeneid (11.597ff.) while attempting some limited level of verisimilitude in its depiction of medieval warfare. The warriors fight on horseback (a practice adopted by the Franks in Carolingian times), first with arrows and javelins from afar (the practice of the Hungarian Avars), and then in hand-to-hand combat with swords (not found in the scene from the ''Aeneid''). The use of ''ecce'' here also reminds us of the poem’s medieval context (see note on line 52). |
}} | }} | ||
|{{Parallel|''Aeneid'' 11.599: ''compositi numero in turmas…'' “Marshalled by number into squadrons…” | |{{Parallel|''Aeneid'' 11.599: ''compositi numero in turmas…'' “Marshalled by number into squadrons…” | ||
| Line 63: | Line 65: | ||
| | | | ||
| | | | ||
| − | |{{Parallel|''Aeneid'' 10.407–8: ''extenditur una/ horrida per latos acies Volcania campos.'' “Vulcan’s bristling battleline spreads unbroken over the broad fields.”<br />11.601–2: ''tum late ferreus hastis/ horret ager campique armis sublimibus ardent.'' “Far and wide the field bristles with the steel of spears, and the plains are ablaze with raised weapons.” | + | |{{Parallel|''Aeneid'' 10.407–8: ''extenditur una / horrida per latos acies Volcania campos.'' “Vulcan’s bristling battleline spreads unbroken over the broad fields.”<br />11.601–2: ''tum late ferreus hastis / horret ager campique armis sublimibus ardent.'' “Far and wide the field bristles with the steel of spears, and the plains are ablaze with raised weapons.” |
}} | }} | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Line 69: | Line 71: | ||
| | | | ||
| | | | ||
| − | |{{Parallel|''Aeneid'' 11.608–9: ''iamque intra iactum teli progressus uterque / substiterat: subito erumpunt clamore.'' “And now in its advance each army had halted within a spear cast of the other; with a sudden shout they dash forth.” | + | |{{Parallel|(Lines 182–83) ''Aeneid'' 11.608–9: ''iamque intra iactum teli progressus uterque / substiterat: subito erumpunt clamore.'' “And now in its advance each army had halted within a spear cast of the other; with a sudden shout they dash forth.” |
}} | }} | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Line 75: | Line 77: | ||
| | | | ||
| | | | ||
| − | |{{Parallel|''Aeneid'' 9.566–67. undique clamor / tollitur. “On all sides a shout goes up.”<br />2.699: ''se tollit ad auras.'' “He raises himself to the airs.” | + | |{{Parallel|(Lines 183-84) ''Aeneid'' 9.566–67. ''undique clamor / tollitur.'' “On all sides a shout goes up.”<br />2.699: ''se tollit ad auras.'' “He raises himself to the airs.” |
}} | }} | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Line 87: | Line 89: | ||
|185 | |185 | ||
| | | | ||
| − | |{{Parallel|''Aeneid'' 11.612–13: ''continuo…'' “At | + | |{{Parallel|''Aeneid'' 11.612–13: ''continuo…'' “At once…”<br />11.610–11: ''fundunt simul undique tela / crebra nivis ritu.'' “Together from all sides they shower weapons as thick as snowflakes.” |
}} | }} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|nowrap | [[Fraxinus]] [[et]] [[cornus]] [[ludum]] [[miscebat]] [[in]] [[unum]], | |nowrap | [[Fraxinus]] [[et]] [[cornus]] [[ludum]] [[miscebat]] [[in]] [[unum]], | ||
| | | | ||
| − | |{{Commentary|''Fraxinus et cornus'': by metonymy, the wooden spears. Ash was the most common material for spear shafts in medieval Europe. Dogwood shafts only occasionally appear in the archaeological record (Vlasatý 2023).<br />''Ludum'': recalling the ''iocis'' (line 102) of war, here and in other instances in the ''Waltharius'', battle is in some way a game. Similarly, in the Old English ''Waldere'', ''Waldere''’s skill in battle is referred to as his skill in ''sweordplega'' “sword-play” (frag. A, line 13). This association is also present in other early medieval literature (cf. Old English ''Beowulf'', lines 1073 and 2039; Old High German ''Ludwigslied'', line 49).<br />For other instances in the ''Waltharius'' of the Latin root of play, ''lud-/lus-'', see lines 541, 734, 740, 766, 782, 794, 903, 956, 1230, 1252, 1291, 1349, 1352, 1424; for the metaphor of athletic games in the use of ''certamen/certare'', see | + | |{{Commentary|''Fraxinus et cornus'': by metonymy, the wooden spears. Ash was the most common material for spear shafts in medieval Europe. Dogwood shafts only occasionally appear in the archaeological record (Vlasatý 2023).<br />''Ludum'': recalling the ''iocis'' (line 102) of war, here and in other instances in the ''Waltharius'', battle is in some way a game. Similarly, in the Old English ''Waldere'', ''Waldere''’s skill in battle is referred to as his skill in ''sweordplega'' “sword-play” (frag. A, line 13). This association is also present in other early medieval literature (cf. Old English ''Beowulf'', lines 1073 and 2039; Old High German ''Ludwigslied'', line 49).<br />For other instances in the ''Waltharius'' of the Latin root of play, ''lud-/lus-'', see lines 541, 734, 740, 766, 782, 794, 903, 956, 1230, 1252, 1291, 1349, 1352, 1424; for the metaphor of athletic games in the use of ''certamen/certare'', see lines 611, 743, 908, 1003, 1301, 1424; ''athleta'', see lines 962, 1046, 1411; ''agon'', see line 1025. For further scholarship on play in the ''Waltharius'', see Ziolkowski 2001. |
}} | }} | ||
|{{Parallel|''Aeneid'' 9.698: ''volat Itala cornus.'' “The Italian dogwood shaft flies.”<br />12.267: ''sonitum dat stridula cornus.'' “The whistling dogwood shaft sings.”<br />12.714: ''fors et virtus miscentur in unum.'' “Chance and valour blend in one.”<br />''Waldere'' frag. A, line 13: ''sweordplega.'' “sword-play.” | |{{Parallel|''Aeneid'' 9.698: ''volat Itala cornus.'' “The Italian dogwood shaft flies.”<br />12.267: ''sonitum dat stridula cornus.'' “The whistling dogwood shaft sings.”<br />12.714: ''fors et virtus miscentur in unum.'' “Chance and valour blend in one.”<br />''Waldere'' frag. A, line 13: ''sweordplega.'' “sword-play.” | ||
| Line 106: | Line 108: | ||
|nowrap | [[Ac]] [[veluti]] [[boreae]] [[sub]] [[tempore]] [[nix]] [[glomerata]] | |nowrap | [[Ac]] [[veluti]] [[boreae]] [[sub]] [[tempore]] [[nix]] [[glomerata]] | ||
| | | | ||
| − | |{{Commentary|''Veluti … haud aliter'': language of epic simile. The image of battle as a storm is common in Greek and Latin poetry from the time of Homer (cf. ''Iliad'' 12.156–158, 278; Aeneid 12.283; Ovid, ''Met.'' 5.157; ''Psychomachia'' 129, 133–134, 173; further examples at Althof 1905, 67), including in Aeneid 11.610–611, which the ''Waltharius'' reworks here, as well as in Germanic poetry (cf. ''Beowulf'' 3117; ''Kudrun'' 503, 861, 1417, 1455; ''Biterolf und Dietlieb'' 10191). | + | |{{Commentary|(Lines 188–89) ''Veluti … haud aliter'': language of epic simile. The image of battle as a storm is common in Greek and Latin poetry from the time of Homer (cf. ''Iliad'' 12.156–158, 278; ''Aeneid'' 12.283; Ovid, ''Met.'' 5.157; ''Psychomachia'' 129, 133–134, 173; further examples at Althof 1905, 67), including in Aeneid 11.610–611, which the ''Waltharius'' reworks here, as well as in Germanic poetry (cf. ''Beowulf'' 3117; ''Kudrun'' 503, 861, 1417, 1455; ''Biterolf und Dietlieb'' 10191). |
}} | }} | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Line 133: | Line 135: | ||
| | | | ||
| | | | ||
| − | |{{Parallel|''Aeneid'' 11. | + | |{{Parallel|(Lines 193–94) ''Aeneid'' 11.612–17: ''adversis Tyrrhenus et acer Aconteus / conixi incurrunt hastis primique ruinam / dant sonitu ingenti perfractaque quadripedantum / pectora pectoribus rumpunt; excussus Aconteus fulminis in morem… praecipitat longe.'' “At once Tyrrhenus and fierce Aconteus charge each other full force with spears, and are first to go down with a mighty crash, breaking and shattering their horses as they collide breast to breast. Flung off like a thunderbolt, Aconteus is hurled headlong far away.”<br />10.360–61: ''aciesque Latinae / concurrunt.'' “The ranks of Latium clash.” |
}} | }} | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Line 150: | Line 152: | ||
| | | | ||
| | | | ||
| − | |{{Parallel|''Aeneid'' 11.762: ''qua se cumque furens medio tulit agmine virgo…'' “Wherever the maiden rides among the ranks in her fury…” | + | |{{Parallel|(Lines 196–97) ''Aeneid'' 11.762: ''qua se cumque furens medio tulit agmine virgo…'' “Wherever the maiden rides among the ranks in her fury…” |
}} | }} | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Line 175: | Line 177: | ||
|200 | |200 | ||
| | | | ||
| − | |{{Parallel|''Aeneid'' 3.563: ''laevam cuncta cohors … petivit.'' “Leftward all our force plied.” | + | |{{Parallel|(Lines 200–201) ''Aeneid'' 3.563: ''laevam cuncta cohors … petivit.'' “Leftward all our force plied.” |
}} | }} | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Line 181: | Line 183: | ||
| | | | ||
| | | | ||
| − | |{{Parallel|''Aeneid'' 9.686: ''agminibus totis qut versi terga dedere.'' “With all their columns [they] are routed and turn to flight.” | + | |{{Parallel|(Lines 201–2) ''Aeneid'' 9.686: ''agminibus totis qut versi terga dedere.'' “With all their columns [they] are routed and turn to flight.” |
}} | }} | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Line 188: | Line 190: | ||
|{{Commentary|''Versis scutis'': they put their shields on their backs to protect them as they flee. | |{{Commentary|''Versis scutis'': they put their shields on their backs to protect them as they flee. | ||
}} | }} | ||
| − | |{{Parallel|''Aeneid'' 11. | + | |{{Parallel|''Aeneid'' 11.618–619: ''versique Latini / reiciunt parmas.'' “The routed Latins cast their shields behind them.”<br />11.623: ''hi fugiunt penitusque datis referuntur habenis'' “The others flee, and retreat far off with loosened rein.”<br />''Georgics'' 2.364: ''palmes agit laxis per purum immisus habenis…'' “The shoot, speeding through the void with loosened reins…”<br />''Aeneid'' 1.62-63: ''qui foedere certo/ et premere et laxas sciret dare iussus habenas.'' “Who, under fixed covenant, should be skilled to tighten and loosen the reins at command.” |
}} | }} | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Line 200: | Line 202: | ||
| | | | ||
| | | | ||
| − | |{{Parallel|''Aeneid'' 12.902 | + | |{{Parallel|''Aeneid'' 12.902; Prudentius, ''Psychomachia'' 31: ''altior insurgens…'' “Rising to his height…” |
}} | }} | ||
|- | |- | ||
| Line 228: | Line 230: | ||
|nowrap | [[Ac]] [[primus]] [[frontem]] [[festa]] [[cum]] [[fronde]] [[revinxit]], | |nowrap | [[Ac]] [[primus]] [[frontem]] [[festa]] [[cum]] [[fronde]] [[revinxit]], | ||
| | | | ||
| − | |{{Commentary|''Frontem festa cum fronde'': alliteration | + | |{{Commentary|''Frontem festa cum fronde'': alliteration<br /><br />(Lines 209–210) ''Lauro'': The poem depicts Waltharius’ victory in a typically Roman fashion. A laurel wreath is more likely a classical reference than a literal description of the homecoming, since the bay laurel, from which laurel wreaths are typically made, is a Mediterranean plant, and it would have a hard time surviving in northern Europe. |
| + | }} | ||
| + | |{{Parallel|(Lines 209–210) ''Aeneid'' 4.459: velleribus niveis et festa fronde revinctum… “Wreathing it with snowy fleeces and festal foliage…”<br />5.71–73: ''“…cingite tempora ramis.”/ Sic fatus velat materna tempora myrto. / hoc Helymus facit, hoc aevi maturus Acestes / hoc puer Ascanius, sequitur quos cetera pubes.'' “‘…Wreathe your brows with leaves.’ So speaking, he crowns his brows with his mother’s myrtle. Thus does Helymus, thus Acestes, ripe of years, thus the boy Ascanius, the rest of the youth following.”<br />''Aeneid'' 5.539: ''cingit viridanti tempora lauro.'' “He binds his brows with green laurel.”<br />7.614: ''sequitur tum cetera pubes.'' “Then the rest of the warriors take up the cry.”<br /> ''Eclogue'' 8.12–13: ''hanc sine tempora circum / inter victricis hederam tibi serpere lauros.'' “Grant that, amid the conqueror’s laurels, this ivy may creep about your brows.” | ||
}} | }} | ||
|- | |- | ||
Latest revision as of 20:30, 28 July 2026
Walther leads the army of the Huns to victory in battle (170–214)
|